CMMC vs NIST: Comparing the Frameworks for Effective Security

CMMC vs NIST: Comparing the Frameworks for Effective Security

If you ever wondered about the similarities and differences between the Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) frameworks then read on. We’ll discuss the cloud security, data access, network security, and user access components of each framework in order to compare and contrast them. 

Overview of the CMMC and NIST frameworks 

The Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) frameworks are two frameworks for addressing cybersecurity risks. The CMMC is a certification program developed by the Department of Defense (DoD) to protect Federal Contract Information (FCI) and Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI). It is a three-level certification program that requires organizations to demonstrate their compliance with a set of security practices in order to receive a certification. The NIST framework is a set of standards and guidelines developed by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). It is designed to help organizations assess, manage, and reduce their cybersecurity risks. It is a flexible framework that provides organizations with a set of best practices and guidance for implementing cybersecurity measures. 

Both frameworks are designed to help organizations improve their cybersecurity posture and protect their data and systems from malicious actors. The CMMC is focused on protecting Federal Contract Information (FCI) and Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI), while the NIST framework is focused on providing organizations with a set of best practices for implementing cybersecurity measures. The CMMC is a certification program that requires organizations to demonstrate their compliance with a set of security practices in order to receive a certification, while the NIST framework is a flexible framework that provides organizations with guidance for implementing cybersecurity measures.

Comparing the CMMC and NIST Frameworks 

The CMMC and NIST frameworks have several similarities and differences. Both frameworks are designed to provide organizations with a comprehensive approach to cybersecurity and are based on best practices for protecting data and networks. However, the CMMC framework is focused specifically on the defense industrial base, while the NIST framework is designed to be used by any organization.

When comparing the two frameworks, cloud security is an area where they differ significantly. The CMMC framework requires organizations to use a cloud service provider that is compliant with the CMMC framework, while the NIST framework does not impose any specific requirements for cloud service providers. Additionally, the CMMC framework has more stringent requirements for data access, network security, and user access than the NIST framework.

Overall, the CMMC framework is more comprehensive and detailed than the NIST framework. While the NIST framework is designed to be applicable to any organization, the CMMC framework is tailored specifically to the defense industrial base. This means that organizations should carefully consider which framework is best suited for their particular cybersecurity needs.

Cloud Security 

The CMMC and NIST frameworks have different requirements when it comes to cloud security. The CMMC framework requires organizations to use a cloud service provider that is compliant with the CMMC framework, while the NIST framework does not impose any specific requirements for cloud service providers. This means that organizations must carefully consider which cloud service provider best meets their needs when using the CMMC framework. 

The CMMC framework also requires organizations to implement additional security measures when using cloud services. These measures include the use of encryption, secure authentication, and the enforcement of access control policies. Additionally, the CMMC framework requires organizations to have a plan in place for responding to any security incidents that may occur. 

Overall, the CMMC framework has more stringent requirements for cloud security than the NIST framework. Organizations should carefully consider which framework is best suited for their particular cybersecurity needs when selecting a cloud service provider.

Data Access 

The CMMC and NIST frameworks both have different requirements when it comes to data access. The CMMC framework requires organizations to implement data access control measures that are designed to protect the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of sensitive data. These measures include the use of authentication, authorization, and encryption. Additionally, organizations must have a plan in place for responding to any data breaches that may occur. 

The NIST framework also requires organizations to implement data access control measures. However, the NIST framework does not specify any specific requirements for these measures. Instead, organizations must develop their own policies and procedures for data access control that meet the requirements of the NIST framework. 

Overall, the CMMC framework has more stringent requirements for data access than the NIST framework. Organizations should carefully evaluate their data access needs and select the framework that best meets their requirements.

Network Security 

The CMMC and NIST frameworks both have different requirements when it comes to network security. The CMMC framework requires organizations to implement a range of security measures to protect their networks, including firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and antivirus software. Organizations must also have a plan in place for responding to any network security incidents that may occur. 

The NIST framework also requires organizations to implement network security measures. However, the NIST framework does not specify any specific requirements for these measures. Instead, organizations must develop their own policies and procedures for network security that meet the requirements of the NIST framework. 

Overall, the CMMC framework has more stringent requirements for network security than the NIST framework. Organizations should carefully evaluate their network security needs and select the framework that best meets their requirements.

User Access 

The CMMC framework requires organizations to implement user access controls to protect their systems from unauthorized access. Organizations must ensure that only authorized users can access their systems and that they can only access the data and functions they need to do their jobs. Organizations must also have a process in place for granting and revoking user access as needed. 

The NIST framework also requires organizations to implement user access controls. However, the framework does not specify any specific requirements for these controls. Organizations must develop their own policies and procedures for user access that meet the requirements of the NIST framework. 

Overall, the CMMC framework has more stringent requirements for user access than the NIST framework. Organizations should carefully evaluate their user access needs and select the framework that best meets their requirements.

Advantages and Disadvantages of CMMC and NIST 

The CMMC and NIST frameworks both provide organizations with guidance on how to secure their networks and data. Each framework has its own advantages and disadvantages that organizations should consider when deciding which one to use. 

One major advantage of the CMMC framework is that it has more specific requirements for user access controls than the NIST framework. This allows organizations to have a more detailed understanding of the user access policies and procedures that must be implemented. Additionally, the CMMC framework also includes additional security requirements, such as the need for organizations to have a continuous monitoring program in place to detect any unauthorized access. 

On the other hand, one of the main disadvantages of the CMMC framework is that it can be more expensive and time consuming to implement than the NIST framework. Organizations must invest in resources to ensure that the requirements are met and that the system is continuously monitored. Additionally, the CMMC framework is only applicable to organizations that are working with the Department of Defense, so it may not be the best option for organizations that do not need to meet the DoD’s security requirements. 

The NIST framework also has its advantages and disadvantages. One advantage is that the framework is less expensive and time consuming to implement than the CMMC framework. Additionally, the NIST framework is applicable to all organizations, regardless of whether they are working with the DoD or not. However, one disadvantage is that the framework does not provide as much detail on user access controls as the CMMC framework. Organizations must develop their own policies and procedures in order to meet the requirements of the NIST framework. 

Advantages of CMMC 

The CMMC framework has several advantages that make it a great choice for organizations that need to meet the Department of Defense’s security requirements. One major advantage is that the framework has more specific requirements for user access controls than the NIST framework. This allows organizations to have a better understanding of the user access policies and procedures that must be implemented in order to meet the DoD’s security requirements. Additionally, the CMMC framework also includes additional security requirements, such as the need for organizations to have a continuous monitoring program in place to detect any unauthorized access. 

The CMMC framework also provides organizations with more detailed guidance on how to secure their networks and data. The framework includes requirements for cloud security, data access, network security, and user access. This allows organizations to better protect their sensitive information and ensure that their systems are secure. Additionally, the framework also provides organizations with a step-by-step approach to implementing the requirements, which makes it easier for organizations to follow the guidelines and stay compliant.

Advantages of NIST 

The NIST framework is a great choice for organizations that need to meet the Department of Defense’s security requirements but are looking for a less stringent solution. One of the biggest advantages of the NIST framework is that it is less prescriptive than the CMMC framework. This allows organizations to have more flexibility when it comes to implementing the security requirements. Additionally, the NIST framework is also more scalable, which makes it easier for organizations to adjust their security measures as their needs change. 

The NIST framework also provides organizations with more detailed guidance on how to secure their networks and data. The framework includes requirements for cloud security, data access, network security, and user access. This allows organizations to better protect their sensitive information and ensure that their systems are secure. Additionally, the framework also provides organizations with a step-by-step approach to implementing the requirements, which makes it easier for organizations to follow the guidelines and stay compliant.

Disadvantages of CMMC 

The CMMC framework can be quite restrictive for organizations that are looking for a less stringent security solution. The framework is very prescriptive and requires organizations to meet all of the security requirements in order to be compliant. This can be challenging for organizations that do not have the resources or expertise to implement all of the requirements. Additionally, the framework can be difficult to scale as the organization’s needs change. This can make it hard for organizations to adjust their security measures as needed. 

The CMMC framework also requires organizations to hire a third-party assessor to review their security measures and ensure that they are compliant. This can be costly for organizations, especially if they need to hire multiple assessors for different areas of their security. Additionally, the process of being assessed can be time-consuming, which can be a challenge for organizations that need to quickly implement the security requirements.

Disadvantages of NIST 

NIST is a much more flexible framework than CMMC, which can be a disadvantage for organizations that need more stringent security measures. NIST does not require organizations to meet all of the security requirements, which can leave gaps in their security measures. Additionally, the framework does not provide as much guidance as CMMC does, so organizations may have difficulty understanding what security measures they should implement. 

NIST also does not require organizations to hire a third-party assessor to review their security measures. This means that organizations must rely on their own internal resources to ensure that their security measures are compliant with the framework. This can be difficult for organizations that do not have the necessary expertise or resources to properly implement the security requirements. 

Finally, NIST does not provide any guidance on how organizations should scale their security measures as their needs change. This can be a challenge for organizations that need to quickly adjust their security measures in order to meet changing requirements.

In Summary

The CMMC and NIST frameworks are both important tools for organizations looking to improve their cybersecurity posture. While both frameworks have their strengths and weaknesses, it is important to understand the differences between them in order to make an informed decision about which framework is best suited for an organization’s needs. 

The CMMC framework provides a more comprehensive set of security requirements, and requires organizations to hire a third-party assessor to review their security measures. This can be beneficial for organizations that need more stringent security measures, but can be costly and time-consuming. 

On the other hand, the NIST framework is much more flexible, and does not require organizations to hire a third-party assessor. This can be beneficial for organizations that need to quickly adjust their security measures in order to meet changing requirements, but can leave gaps in their security measures if they do not have the necessary expertise or resources to properly implement the security requirements. 

Ultimately, the decision of which framework to use should be based on an organization’s specific needs and resources. By understanding the differences between the CMMC and NIST frameworks, organizations can make an informed decision that best suits their needs.

Scroll to Top

Perks

Tresorit

Tresorit is the gold standard for secure cloud storage and collaboration, offering end-to-end encryption to safeguard sensitive data. Trusted by 11,000+ organizations, it enables seamless, zero-knowledge file sharing, encrypted storage, eSign, and email encryption. With compliance-ready solutions for GDPR, HIPAA, and NIS2, Tresorit empowers businesses and individuals to stay in control of their data without compromising security or ease of use.

Perks

EasyDMARC

Simplify And Automate Your DMARC Journey.

Protect your company reputation, ensure compliance with industry regulations, and improve your domains’ performance with our time-saving, all-in-one DMARC service platform.

93% of all hacking attacks and data breaches involve email. The numbers are rising, and 500 million dollars every year are scammed by phishing attacks. Implement DMARC to secure your company!

Perks

RunPod

RunPod is a cloud platform that lets small teams deploy full-stack AI apps without managing infrastructure. With on-demand high-performance GPUs, users can easily launch, train, and optimize AI workloads at scale.

Perks

CarePatron

Carepatron is an all-in-one practice management platform designed to help health and wellness professionals streamline their workflows and deliver better care. With Carepatron, you can manage appointments with ease, conduct secure telehealth sessions, process online payments, create accurate client notes and records, and much more. Carepatron allows practitioners to save time, focus more on their patients, and deliver better outcomes … all while being HIPAA compliant.

Perks

IRSplus

Have you checked if you have unclaimed tax credits sitting with the IRS? A lot of small businesses do, and with the IRS moratorium on new ERC tax refund filings at an end, it might be worth it to try. IRSplus makes it easy to do a quick check.

Perks

MioCommerce

MioCommerce is the all-in-one solution to get customers, sell services instantly, manage your jobs, and boost engagement.Save 28% of your time when you automate your service business.

MioCommerce provides the Home & Commercial Service SME a 1-stop-shop to build and scale their own online and offline brand (E-Service Store), instantly acquire new customers both On & Off-line as well as simplify & automate their entire operations.

Perks

Design Pickle

Design Pickle is your go-to solution for on-demand graphic design. Whether you’re a business, agency, or individual, get unlimited design requests with fast turnarounds and no hidden fees. Skip the hassle of hiring freelancers or managing in-house teams. With Design Pickle, you get consistent, high-quality designs every time, supported by a dedicated team of experts who know your brand inside and out.

Perks

Lusha

Lusha empowers over 280,000 go-to-market teams with access to the most accurate and compliant global database of companies and decision-makers.

Powered by insights from 1.5M+ users, Lusha delivers tailored recommendations on who to connect with, when, and why—helping you focus on the right opportunities at the right time.

Whether you’re in sales, marketing, or recruitment, Lusha equips you with the insights and data to work smarter, connect faster, and achieve exceptional results.

Terms and conditions

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Perks

Taxfyle

Taxfyle simplifies tax filing by connecting clients with licensed Tax Pros for seamless, accurate, and affordable services. Whether handling personal or business taxes, our platform ensures convenience and quality, delivering results that meet your clients’ needs. By partnering with Taxfyle, you provide a trusted, scalable solution that enhances customer satisfaction and streamlines their tax experience.

Perks

Extensis

Extensis Connect manages fonts and other creative assets with intelligent font usage and license compliance reporting, so libraries stay in good graces and growing teams create more effectively.’,
‘With Connect + Insight, you can add Project Risk Scanning to your superpowers. Identify font usage risks within projects before they get to production, receive suggested steps for resolution, and fix files before they cause problems.

Perks

Warmy

Warmy.io addresses the issue of poor email deliverability by enhancing users’ sender reputation. This helps ensure that emails reach recipients’ inboxes rather than being marked as spam. Warmy.io benefits businesses in email marketing and outreach, with over 83% of B2B companies around the world using email for these purposes.

Perks

Hide My Name

HideMyName VPN has established itself as a trusted cybersecurity solution for users worldwide. The service combines a user-friendly interface with robust security features, ensuring a comfortable and secure browsing experience. With fast servers, reliable connections, and round-the-clock customer support, HideMyName VPN helps users maintain privacy and access geo-restricted content with confidence.

Perks

Looka

Looka is an AI-powered logo maker that gives business owners a quick and affordable way to create a beautiful brand. The platform takes a non-templated approach to logos to generate tons of unique options that you can customize in an easy-to-use editor. Answer a few questions about your business and design preferences, and you’ll immediately see a wide variety of logos to start saving and editing.

Perks

Getscreen.me

Getscreen.me is a cloud-based software providing a remote access via a browser. Connection is performed via a link without installing additional programs. The software has integrations with Telegram, Google Chrome, Jira Service Desk and via API.

The service is suitable for administration, technical support, as well as for remote connection to an office computer from home. Windows, macOS, Linux and Android versions are available.

Perks

MRPeasy.com

MRPeasy is a seriously powerful yet easy-to-use manufacturing software. It gives you everything you need to manage your manufacturing and distribution. Ideal for companies with 10 – 200 employees.

Everything you need to manage your manufacturing and distribution: Production planning, inventory & stock, sales & CRM, team, purchasing, and accounting.

Perks

Dext

Dext is the world leader in bookkeeping automation, empowering business owners to simplify accounting processes. Users can capture receipts, invoices, and financial records via mobile, email, and integrations with over 1,600 suppliers. Dext supports managing employee expense claims, automates workflows with recurring suppliers, and processes supplier statements seamlessly.

Terms and conditions

15% off first year (monthly or annual)

Perks

Gusto

Gusto makes it easy to pay your team, manage benefits, and protect your startup from day one. Run payroll as many times as you need to each month — we don’t charge extra. Your team gets paid in just a few clicks. Gusto supports over 9,000 plans by national carriers in all 50 states, plus D.C. Health benefits through Gusto include medical, dental, vision, HSA and FSA health plans, life and disability.

Perks

Apollo

Apollo.io provides sales and marketing teams with easy access to verified contact data for over 210 million B2B contacts, along with tools to engage and convert these contacts in one unified platform. By helping revenue professionals find the most accurate contact information and automating the outreach process, Apollo.io turns prospects into customers.

Terms and conditions

50% off Apollo’s annual Basic and Professional plans. This promotion is available to startups for their first year.

  • Valid for new customers only (with a corporate email*).*
  • 20 or fewer employees (the discount will apply for up to 5 seats*).*
  • 50% off of our Basic or Professional annual plans only.

Perks

Zonka

Zonka Feedback is a versatile survey software that empowers businesses to gather, measure, and act on customer feedback. With multi-channel surveys, real-time insights, and advanced analytics, it enhances customer experiences. The platform integrates seamlessly with tools like Zapier, HubSpot, and Salesforce, enabling data-driven decisions.

Perks

NordPass

NordPass is a password manager created by Nord Security, the cybersecurity brand behind NordVPN. Its intuitive interface makes it easy for anyone to securely generate, store, manage, and share passwords, passkeys, notes, and payment information—no tech skills required. With end-to-end encryption, zero-knowledge architecture, and 24/7 tech support, NordPass ensures privacy and security for your digital life.

Perks

Tax1099

Tax1099 is an IRS-authorized eFiling platform, trusted by over 500,000 businesses to simplify tax form filing. With Tax1099, users can electronically file 1099s, W-2s, ACA forms, and more. The platform automates key tasks like form completion, error checking, and real-time TIN matching, and integrates seamlessly with accounting software such as QuickBooks, Xero, and Bill.com.

Perks

ElectricAI

IT Management Software for SMBs

  • Gain single-point visibility into your device inventory, keeping you compliant
  • Get real-time, easy to understand (for non-IT folks), insights into the health of your devices and cyber security tips
  • Take action on your device security directly in platform and keep your device security up to date

Terms and conditions

Go to the link and add “Phalanx” as the Networking name in the partner box on Electric AI

Perks

Mercury

Mercury is the fintech ambitious companies use for banking* and all their financial workflows. With a powerful bank account at the center of their operations, companies can make better financial decisions and ensure every dollar spent aligns with company priorities. That’s why over 200K startups choose Mercury to confidently run all their financial operations with the precision, control, and focus they need to operate at their best.

*Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided by Choice Financial Group, Column N.A., and Evolve Bank & Trust, Members FDIC.

Perks

ClickUp

With over 12M users and valued at $4B, ClickUp helps teams at companies like Netix, Spotify, and IBM manage everything from product development to marketing to sales. Recent updates include the introduction of Chat, Whiteboards 3.0, AI Knowledge Management and more coming in early 2025 — all in service of our goal of letting people do all their work in ClickUp, making them more productive and giving back at least 20% of their time to dedicate to other things.

Perks

Phalanx MUZE

Phalanx MUZE transforms the way you protect your business files by seamlessly encrypting data stored on desktops, Google Drive, OneDrive, and more. Whether your team works locally or in the cloud, MUZE ensures your files are secure, compliant, and easy to manage—without disrupting workflows. Designed for businesses looking to reduce risks from ransomware, insider threats, or accidental data leaks, MUZE delivers robust protection that integrates directly into your existing tools. Experience automated security tailored for modern work environments.

Terms and conditions

This promotion provides a 50% discount on the Phalanx MUZE subscription for the first two years. Offer valid only for new customers and cannot be combined with any other promotions or discounts. Discount applies to the base subscription fee only. After the two-year promotional period, the subscription renews at the standard rate unless canceled. Terms and conditions are subject to change.

Perks

Phalanx.io

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Terms and conditions

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Specifies total amount of data that can be shared per secure links.

Gives you direct access to support through phone or video calls, for immediate assistance.

Offers faster email support, ensuring your queries are prioritized.

Provides assistance and answers your questions via email.

Lets you brand the file send page with your company’s logo and colors, providing a professional and secure way to send files.

Extends protection to more complex or specialized document types, ensuring all your data is secure.

Ensures common types of office documents, like Word and Excel files, are protected and managed securely.

The ability to set when your links will expire.

Allows you to see a record of who’s looked at your link, what time they looked at it, and if they downloaded the file.

Number of File Receives

How many file links you can generate to send files.

Lets you safely preview PDF files without the need to download them, adding an extra layer of security.

Provides a secure way for people outside your company to send you files, ensuring they’re protected during transfer.

Allows you to share files securely through links, ensuring that only people with the link can access them with many ways to restrict access.